Tagging/Watsan
From Map Kibera
(Difference between revisions)
Ebrelsford (Talk | contribs) (→Review) |
Ebrelsford (Talk | contribs) (→Changes) |
||
| Line 109: | Line 109: | ||
* Names | * Names | ||
** Fixed obvious typos | ** Fixed obvious typos | ||
| - | ** | + | ** Removed generic water names: |
*** "Dumping site" | *** "Dumping site" | ||
*** "Private toilets" | *** "Private toilets" | ||
*** "Public toilets" | *** "Public toilets" | ||
| - | *** "Water point" | + | *** "Water point" (did not set <tt>watsan:description</tt>) |
| - | *** "Water tank" | + | *** "Water tank" (set <tt>watsan:description</tt>="water tank") |
| - | *** "Water tap" | + | *** "Water tap" (set <tt>watsan:description</tt>="water tap") |
=== Notes === | === Notes === | ||
Revision as of 18:45, 12 October 2010
Contents |
Water and Sanitation tags
| currently in Kibera | other applicable/existing tags | notes |
|---|---|---|
watsan:bathroom=yes | amenity=toilets | This is an actual bath ... these are often offered as public services in Kibera, often with a toilet as well. amenity=toilet is not entirely correct |
watsan:dumping_site=yes | amenity=waste_disposal | This is an waste disposal site, without proper formal structure. |
watsan:pee_point=yes | amenity=toilets | This is not a formal toilet, but a place very commonly used for peeing |
watsan:recycling=yes | amenity=recycling | |
watsan:toilet_private=yes | amenity=toilets | What about using access=private or relying on operator:type=private rather than splitting these into toilet_private/toilet_public? yes, that change makes sense |
watsan:toilet_public=yes | amenity=toilets | |
watsan:urban_agriculture=yes | leisure=garden | yes |
watsan:water_private=yes | amenity=drinking_water man_made=water_tower landuse=reservoir natural=water | amenity=drinking_water assumes water is drinkable--is this valid?
landuse=reservoir implies a large, polygonal reservoir, which seems unlikely natural=water implies a spring or lake, which seems unlikely |
watsan:water_public=yes | amenity=drinking_water | Around half of the features with this tag also include operator:type=private. it means the water is publicly accessible, but for sale by a private operator |
Review
User:Ebrelsford completed an initial review of these tags on October 8, 2010 and committed the resulting changes.
Found (as of October 3, 2010)
| tag | instances |
|---|---|
| watsan:bathroom=yes | 43 |
| watsan:dumping_site=yes | 33 |
| watsan:pee_point=yes | 8 |
| watsan:recycling=yes | 5 |
| watsan:toilet_private=yes | 35 |
| watsan:toilet_public=yes | 63 |
| watsan:urban_agriculture=yes | 10 |
| watsan:water_private=yes | 137 |
| watsan:water_public=yes | 128 |
Changes
- Add amenity tags:
- amenity=toilets to features with
- watsan:bathroom=yes
- watsan:pee_point=yes
- watsan:toilet_private=yes
- watsan:toilet_public=yes
- amenity=waste_disposal to features with
- watsan:dumping_site=yes
- amenity=toilets to features with
- Add operator:type=private to features with no operator:type=* tagged
- watsan:toilet_private
- watsan:water_private
- Add man_made=windmill where appropriate
- Remove watsan:toilet_public=no from features tagged watsan:toilet_private=yes and vice versa.
- Remove watsan features from ways
- Split features with multiple watsan:*=yes tags
- Except features with watsan:toilet_.*=yes and watsan:bathroom=yes
- Names
- Fixed obvious typos
- Removed generic water names:
- "Dumping site"
- "Private toilets"
- "Public toilets"
- "Water point" (did not set watsan:description)
- "Water tank" (set watsan:description="water tank")
- "Water tap" (set watsan:description="water tap")
Notes
Is there a difference between a "water point", "water tank", and "water tap"? If so, should we tag these differently? Right now the only consistent difference seems to be in name.
-- A water tank is a reservoir, usually a large above ground container; and a water tap is a spigot connected to a line. Water point, could be either.
A few nodes with watsan:other=yes mention being start/end points of terraces. Not sure what to do with these, if anything.
