Tagging/Watsan

From Map Kibera

(Difference between revisions)
Jump to: navigation, search
(Changes)
(Water and Sanitation tags)
 
(13 intermediate revisions not shown)
Line 2: Line 2:
{| class="wikitable" border="1"
{| class="wikitable" border="1"
-
!currently in Kibera!!other applicable tags!!notes
+
!currently in Kibera!!other applicable/existing tags!!notes
|-
|-
|<pre>watsan:bathroom=yes</pre>
|<pre>watsan:bathroom=yes</pre>
|<pre>amenity=toilets</pre>
|<pre>amenity=toilets</pre>
-
|Redundant considering toilet_private, toilet_public?
+
| This is an actual bath ... these are often offered as public services in Kibera, often with a toilet as well. amenity=toilet is not entirely correct
 +
Sometimes <tt>shower=yes</tt> is used. This could work here, but it might not hurt to do something more official?
|-
|-
|<pre>watsan:dumping_site=yes</pre>
|<pre>watsan:dumping_site=yes</pre>
|<pre>amenity=waste_disposal</pre>
|<pre>amenity=waste_disposal</pre>
-
|
+
| This is an waste disposal site, without proper formal structure.
|-
|-
|<pre>watsan:pee_point=yes</pre>
|<pre>watsan:pee_point=yes</pre>
|<pre>amenity=toilets</pre>
|<pre>amenity=toilets</pre>
-
|
+
| This is not a formal toilet, but a place very commonly used for peeing.
 +
Seems <tt>informal=yes</tt> might make sense for a lot of things in Kibera.
|-
|-
|<pre>watsan:recycling=yes</pre>
|<pre>watsan:recycling=yes</pre>
Line 21: Line 23:
|-
|-
|<pre>watsan:toilet_private=yes</pre>
|<pre>watsan:toilet_private=yes</pre>
-
|<pre>amenity=toilets</pre>
+
|<pre>amenity=toilets
-
|What about using <tt>access=private</tt> or relying on <tt>operator:type=private</tt> rather than splitting these into toilet_private/toilet_public?
+
access=private</pre>
 +
|
|-
|-
|<pre>watsan:toilet_public=yes</pre>
|<pre>watsan:toilet_public=yes</pre>
-
|<pre>amenity=toilets</pre>
+
|<pre>amenity=toilets
 +
access=yes</pre>
|
|
 +
|-
 +
|<pre>watsan:biocentre=yes</pre>
 +
|<pre>amenity=toilets</pre>
 +
| http://www.umande.org/bio_centers.html has more info on biocentres. decomposes waste to create cooking gas.
|-
|-
|<pre>watsan:urban_agriculture=yes</pre>
|<pre>watsan:urban_agriculture=yes</pre>
|<pre>leisure=garden</pre>
|<pre>leisure=garden</pre>
-
|
+
| yes
|-
|-
|<pre>watsan:water_private=yes</pre>
|<pre>watsan:water_private=yes</pre>
|<pre>amenity=drinking_water
|<pre>amenity=drinking_water
-
man_made=water_tower
+
access=private</pre>
-
landuse=reservoir
+
|
-
natural=water</pre>
+
-
|<tt>amenity=drinking_water</tt> assumes water is drinkable--is this valid?
+
|-
|-
|<pre>watsan:water_public=yes</pre>
|<pre>watsan:water_public=yes</pre>
-
|<pre>amenity=drinking_water</pre>
+
|<pre>amenity=drinking_water
-
|Around half of the features with this tag also include <tt>operator:type=private</tt>.
+
access=yes</pre>
 +
|Around half of the features with this tag also include <tt>operator:type=private</tt>. ''it means the water is publicly accessible, but for sale by a private operator''
|}
|}
-
 
== Review ==
== Review ==
-
[[User:Ebrelsford]] is in the middle of reviewing these tags.
+
[[User:Ebrelsford]] completed an initial review of these tags on October 8, 2010 and committed the resulting [http://www.openstreetmap.org/browse/changeset/5986772 changes].
-
=== Found ===
+
=== Found (as of October 3, 2010) ===
{| class="wikitable" border="1"
{| class="wikitable" border="1"
!tag!!instances
!tag!!instances
Line 107: Line 113:
* Names
* Names
** Fixed obvious typos
** Fixed obvious typos
-
** Standardize obviously generic ones:
+
** Removed generic water names:
 +
*** "Dumping site"
*** "Private toilets"
*** "Private toilets"
*** "Public toilets"
*** "Public toilets"
-
*** "Water point"
+
*** "Water point" (did not set <tt>watsan:description</tt>)
-
*** "Water tank"
+
*** "Water tank" (set <tt>watsan:description</tt>="water tank")
-
*** "Water tap"
+
*** "Water tap" (set <tt>watsan:description</tt>="water tap")
=== Notes ===
=== Notes ===
-
It's pretty common for a feature to have multiple <tt>watsan:*=yes</tt> tags. I've left these alone where they could make sense (eg, <tt>watsan:bathroom=yes</tt> and <tt>watsan:recycling=yes</tt>.
+
Is there a difference between a "water point", "water tank", and "water tap"? If so, should we tag these differently? Right now the only consistent difference seems to be in name.
 +
 
 +
-- A water tank is a reservoir, usually a large above ground container; and a water tap is a spigot connected to a line. Water point, could be either.
A few nodes with <tt>watsan:other=yes</tt> mention being start/end points of terraces. Not sure what to do with these, if anything.
A few nodes with <tt>watsan:other=yes</tt> mention being start/end points of terraces. Not sure what to do with these, if anything.

Current revision as of 19:31, 13 December 2010

Contents

Water and Sanitation tags

currently in Kiberaother applicable/existing tagsnotes
watsan:bathroom=yes
amenity=toilets
This is an actual bath ... these are often offered as public services in Kibera, often with a toilet as well. amenity=toilet is not entirely correct

Sometimes shower=yes is used. This could work here, but it might not hurt to do something more official?

watsan:dumping_site=yes
amenity=waste_disposal
This is an waste disposal site, without proper formal structure.
watsan:pee_point=yes
amenity=toilets
This is not a formal toilet, but a place very commonly used for peeing.

Seems informal=yes might make sense for a lot of things in Kibera.

watsan:recycling=yes
amenity=recycling
watsan:toilet_private=yes
amenity=toilets
access=private
watsan:toilet_public=yes
amenity=toilets
access=yes
watsan:biocentre=yes
amenity=toilets
http://www.umande.org/bio_centers.html has more info on biocentres. decomposes waste to create cooking gas.
watsan:urban_agriculture=yes
leisure=garden
yes
watsan:water_private=yes
amenity=drinking_water
access=private
watsan:water_public=yes
amenity=drinking_water
access=yes
Around half of the features with this tag also include operator:type=private. it means the water is publicly accessible, but for sale by a private operator

Review

User:Ebrelsford completed an initial review of these tags on October 8, 2010 and committed the resulting changes.

Found (as of October 3, 2010)

taginstances
watsan:bathroom=yes 43
watsan:dumping_site=yes 33
watsan:pee_point=yes 8
watsan:recycling=yes 5
watsan:toilet_private=yes 35
watsan:toilet_public=yes 63
watsan:urban_agriculture=yes 10
watsan:water_private=yes 137
watsan:water_public=yes 128

Changes

  • Add amenity tags:
    • amenity=toilets to features with
      • watsan:bathroom=yes
      • watsan:pee_point=yes
      • watsan:toilet_private=yes
      • watsan:toilet_public=yes
    • amenity=waste_disposal to features with
      • watsan:dumping_site=yes
  • Add operator:type=private to features with no operator:type=* tagged
    • watsan:toilet_private
    • watsan:water_private
  • Add man_made=windmill where appropriate
  • Remove watsan:toilet_public=no from features tagged watsan:toilet_private=yes and vice versa.
  • Remove watsan features from ways
  • Split features with multiple watsan:*=yes tags
    • Except features with watsan:toilet_.*=yes and watsan:bathroom=yes
  • Names
    • Fixed obvious typos
    • Removed generic water names:
      • "Dumping site"
      • "Private toilets"
      • "Public toilets"
      • "Water point" (did not set watsan:description)
      • "Water tank" (set watsan:description="water tank")
      • "Water tap" (set watsan:description="water tap")

Notes

Is there a difference between a "water point", "water tank", and "water tap"? If so, should we tag these differently? Right now the only consistent difference seems to be in name.

-- A water tank is a reservoir, usually a large above ground container; and a water tap is a spigot connected to a line. Water point, could be either.

A few nodes with watsan:other=yes mention being start/end points of terraces. Not sure what to do with these, if anything.

Personal tools